Testing v. informal reasoning
Read OriginalThis article is a critique of the idea, presented in 'Out of the Tar Pit,' that informal reasoning is more important than testing. The author argues that for inherently complex systems like modern CPUs or tax code, testing is indispensable because human reasoning is fallible and cannot fully grasp such complexity. The piece uses examples from hardware and software to defend the necessity of testing over pure informal reasoning.
Comments
No comments yet
Be the first to share your thoughts!
Browser Extension
Get instant access to AllDevBlogs from your browser
Top of the Week
1
Using Browser Apis In React Practical Guide
Jivbcoop
•
2 votes
2
Better react-hook-form Smart Form Components
Maarten Hus
•
2 votes
3
Top picks — 2026 January
Paweł Grzybek
•
1 votes
4
In Praise of –dry-run
Henrik Warne
•
1 votes
5
Deep Learning is Powerful Because It Makes Hard Things Easy - Reflections 10 Years On
Ferenc Huszár
•
1 votes
6
Vibe coding your first iOS app
William Denniss
•
1 votes
7
AGI, ASI, A*I – Do we have all we need to get there?
John D. Cook
•
1 votes
8
Quoting Thariq Shihipar
Simon Willison
•
1 votes
9
Dew Drop – January 15, 2026 (#4583)
Alvin Ashcraft
•
1 votes